The Spanish Grand Prix was received by McLaren’s Oscar Piastri, who took his fifth victory of the season from team-mate Lando Norris.
However the story of the race was the controversial sequence of occasions surrounding Max Verstappen within the closing laps.
Commercial
Verstappen appeared to drive intentionally into George Russell’s Mercedes, a couple of laps after he left the monitor whereas battling for place with the Briton.
Following the race in Barcelona, BBC Sport F1 correspondent Andrew Benson solutions your newest questions.
Ought to Max Verstappen have been given a much bigger penalty for his actions within the Spanish Grand Prix? Intentionally ramming one other driver feels just like the kind of motion which might have led to a ban for the next race in occasions previous – John
Everybody may have their very own opinion on this.
It was clear after the race that many individuals in Components 1 didn’t assume Verstappen had behaved appropriately in his collision with George Russell’s Mercedes at Flip 5, and he has now
Commercial
Requested whether or not Verstappen ought to have had the black flag – which disqualifies a driver from the race – Russell mentioned: “If it was actually deliberate, then completely. Since you can’t intentionally crash into one other driver.
“We’re placing our lives on the road. We’re lucky the automobiles are as protected as they’re nowadays. However we should not take it with no consideration.”
However penalties are on the stewards’ discretion and on this case they determined to offer Verstappen a 10-second penalty, a comparatively extreme sanction, and three factors on his licence.
Why was this adjudged to be a much less severe offence than Russell chopping the chicane to go a Williams in Monaco and never giving the place again, for which he received a drive-through penalty?
Commercial
The stewards’ verdict didn’t tackle that, and an FIA spokesperson mentioned they might not converse for the stewards as they’re impartial.
These three factors do put Verstappen one away from a ban. Which implies any transgression within the subsequent two races in Canada and Austria, and Verstappen can be compelled to overlook the subsequent grand prix.
After that, some factors come off his licence as a result of they transcend their yr’s expiry date.
Given the stewards weren’t going to take any additional motion in opposition to Max Verstappen for leaving the monitor and gaining a bonus, do you assume Purple Bull pulled the set off too early in ordering him to offer the place again to George Russell? Danny
With the good thing about hindsight, this was certainly one of two errors Purple Bull made within the Spanish Grand Prix.
Commercial
After the stewards launched an inquiry into the Verstappen-Russell incident in Flip One, Purple Bull determined to order Verstappen to offer the place again.
Crew principal Christian Horner mentioned the choice was primarily based “on latest expertise and taking a look at latest incidents”.
Verstappen had saved fourth place by taking to the escape highway after the 2 had made gentle contact whereas Russell tried a passing transfer. He believed he was justified in holding the place as a result of he felt the Mercedes driver had barged him off the monitor.
Horner mentioned Purple Bull had contacted FIA race management and obtained nothing again and that, because it had gone to the stewards, “it seemed for all intents and functions that it was going to be a penalty”.
Commercial
Horner added: “The argument is, was George beneath management at that time limit? Would he have made the nook? We have seen so many events this yr the place penalties have been given.
“You are anticipating to get a penalty, in order that’s why it was, ‘OK, have you learnt what? We will have to offer this place up.'”
The stewards’ verdict was printed a while after the race. It mentioned that Russell had “momentarily misplaced management of the automotive and collided” with Verstappen, who “didn’t intentionally depart the monitor”. Consequently, it mentioned, they took no additional motion.
In different phrases, of their view, Verstappen might have justifiably saved the place.
Commercial
There are two elements of the racing tips in play right here. To be entitled to be given house – ie, to have been judged to have received the nook – the motive force overtaking on the within has to have his entrance axle “at the very least alongside the mirror of the opposite automotive previous to and on the apex”.
Russell appears to have complied with this.
However the automotive should additionally “be pushed in a completely managed method notably from entry to apex”.
This, the stewards determined, Russell had not. And that was additionally Verstappen’s opinion.
Horner mentioned: “With hindsight, was it a mistake? Yeah, however I feel that is the place it could be good, because the referee, as a race director, to both say, ‘Play on,’ or ‘you have to give it again.’ It’s extremely arduous for the staff, subjectively, to try to make that decision, since you’re happening historic precedents.”
Commercial
The second determination Purple Bull received improper, Horner admitted, was the choice to pit Verstappen for recent arduous tyres beneath the security automotive, one which Verstappen instantly questioned vociferously as soon as he was again on monitor.
Horner acknowledged they need to have left him out on his gentle tyres. “He would have gotten handed by the 2 McLarens. Would he have gotten handed by (Charles) Leclerc? However you may solely go along with the data you must hand.”
Might the biking accident damage, a second indignant outburst and really poor performances sign the start of the top for Lance Stroll at Aston Martin? – Peter
There are a whole lot of unanswered questions on this case, however one which has been answered is whether or not after qualifying on Saturday.
Commercial
On Sunday morning, this author and one other journalist requested an Aston Martin spokesperson whether or not claims that Stroll had banged gear about, sworn at staff members, and stormed out of the storage have been true.
The spokesperson didn’t deny the story. They mentioned: “Lance was upset.”
Later that night, an Aston Martin supply contacted BBC Sport to disclaim that something was damaged or that Stroll swore at colleagues. However not the central fact of the story.
This got here to gentle after Aston Martin introduced on Saturday night that Stroll had withdrawn from the race due to ache in his hand and wrist, which they mentioned his medical marketing consultant believed was associated to the operation he had after struggling two damaged wrists in a biking accident earlier than the 2023 season.
Commercial
There are a few methods of taking a look at this.
On the one hand, for Stroll to be so irritated, apparently about being knocked out in Q2 and being 0.535secs slower than team-mate Fernando Alonso, suggests he’s very invested in his try to achieve success in F1.
Stroll’s earlier outburst after qualifying got here in an identical state of affairs, when he had been over a second slower than Alonso in Qatar in 2023.
However it is vitally uncommon for an F1 driver to intentionally skip a race for an damage or ache of this type.
Many drivers race with accidents, and Stroll himself raced with two fractures at first of 2023, after the operation that the staff say his medical marketing consultant believes is on the root of his present predicament.
Commercial
As as to if that is the start of the top for Stroll, solely he is aware of.
He has a seat on the staff so long as he needs. His father Lawrence owns it, and he basically purchased it so Lance might have a drive in F1, with the purpose of changing into world champion.
Stroll is way from probably the most communicative or amenable of F1 drivers with the media. However, each time he’s requested, he all the time says he’s dedicated to F1 and the staff.
Is there any proof that McLaren have made modifications to cope with how Lando Norris was struggling to become familiar with the automotive in qualifying. Is that this the most important distinction between final yr, the place Norris was clearly the faster McLaren driver, and this yr the place Oscar Piastri has had a transparent edge? – Tom
Norris has admitted within the first a part of this season that a side of the behaviour of the McLaren automotive has been affecting his qualifying type, notably what staff boss Andrea Stella says is a “numb” feeling from the entrance axle.
Commercial
To resolve this situation, McLaren have been working with Norris on his driving, and have mentioned that upgrades can be launched to the automotive to assist the problem.
Norris felt that he made a breakthrough with this in Monaco, After he certified second to team-mate Oscar Piastri in Spain, he was requested whether or not he nonetheless felt he had made that progress.
Norris replied: “The velocity was simply there at this time. And generally you simply do not put the laps in. Right this moment was good.
“I used to be just a little bit behind at first of qualifying and I caught up properly. I do know the place I misplaced that point on the ultimate lap. It was simply making an attempt just a little bit an excessive amount of and simply not being fairly tidy sufficient – particularly round a lap like Barcelona.
Commercial
“One little oversteer in Flip One, Flip Two, you type of already know it is going to be a tough remainder of the lap. So, it is nonetheless good. I nonetheless really feel positive. I am pleased with second, particularly in Barcelona – it is not the top of the world. So, a constructive weekend.”
As for the dynamic between the 2 drivers, effectively, that is nonetheless enjoying out. Let’s have a look at how the subsequent few races pan out.
Why did Ferrari depart Lewis Hamilton out so lengthy earlier than his second pit cease? He was two seconds in entrance of George Russell, who had made his second cease and afterwards he was 10 seconds behind. What’s going on with that pit wall? – Mike
This subject was not coated in Ferrari staff principal Frederic Vasseur’s post-race briefing. However keep in mind that operating lengthy is a normal tactic in Spain, to offer the motive force a tyre offset in opposition to a rival.
Commercial
Russell was solely two seconds behind Hamilton when Mercedes pitted him on lap 41, effectively inside undercut vary. So it could make sense for Ferrari to depart Hamilton out for precisely this purpose.
In any case, this isn’t the most important situation surrounding Hamilton after the Spanish Grand Prix.
The seven-time champion was downcast after the race. He mumbled by means of his media briefing, giving very brief solutions, if he answered questions in any respect, earlier than excusing himself after a few minutes.
He mentioned: “I do not know why it was so dangerous”, and mentioned it was the “worst race I’ve skilled, balance-wise.” There have been “zero” positives, he mentioned.
Commercial
Hamilton’s concern, presumably, was his lack of tempo.
He began the race two locations forward of team-mate Charles Leclerc. It was an encouraging qualifying efficiency by Hamilton, even when the context was that Leclerc’s session had gone barely awry as he tried to avoid wasting two recent units of medium tyres for the race.
Leclerc handed Mercedes’ Kimi Antonelli instantly and trailed shut behind Hamilton till lap 10, when Ferrari ordered Hamilton to let him by.
Within the subsequent 5 laps earlier than his pit cease, Hamilton misplaced just below 4 seconds to his team-mate.
Leclerc stopped for the primary time a lap later than Hamilton. By the point the Monegasque stopped once more on lap 40, Hamilton was 10 seconds adrift.
Commercial
That is hardly a catastrophe, however neither is it what Hamilton expects of himself.
Within the remaining a part of the race, Vasseur mentioned, Hamilton had an issue on his automotive, the identification of which he didn’t specify.
“He did 70% of the race in entrance of Russell,” Vasseur mentioned. “I am unsure that Russell mentioned that the race was a catastrophe. Then we had a difficulty on the automotive, the final stint (after) the security automotive. The consequence just isn’t good, however he did 45 laps in entrance of Russell.”
