The brand new Components 1 guidelines have sparked debate and differing opinions on a variety of issues, not least what makes for good racing.
F1 boasted in regards to the enormous variety of overtakes within the season-opening Australian Grand Prix, which was lauded by some however ridiculed by most. It uncovered a problem on the very coronary heart of racing: what makes for good racing and is extra overtaking all the time higher.
Commercial
Our worldwide writers present their views.
The optics are sometimes deceptive
Stuart Codling, Autosport:
Among the many extra spurious items of cant issued by the industrial rights holder to defend the 2026 Components 1 rules is that “the followers” have been complaining for years that they wished to see extra overtaking, and that this has now been delivered. So what are you all complaining about, then? Pipe down!
F1 factors to fan-satisfaction surveys, which seem to point {that a} important proportion of the viewers is of the more-is-better persuasion. It’s, nonetheless, simple to poke holes within the methodology of those statistics.
Commercial
The argument towards more-is-better is that when overtaking strikes are showered round like confetti, and based mostly on little greater than relative battery ranges, the spectacle is devalued. Particularly so when the battery ranges and software program algorithms that decide who passes whom are background operations, largely invisible to the spectator.
It is a legitimate argument – however is shortage in itself an excellent factor? Possibly, perhaps not.
Fernando Alonso, Renault R25, leads Michael Schumacher, Ferrari F2005
Fernando Alonso, Renault R25, leads Michael Schumacher, Ferrari F2005
There are those that maintain that the 2005 San Marino Grand Prix is among the many most fun races of all time just because didn’t handle to overhaul within the closing half of the race. However you possibly can additionally argue this can be a textbook instance of so-called ‘peak-end impact’, the cognitive bias whereby viewers over-rate an expertise as an entire due to the feelings they felt at its peak.
Commercial
Certainly, there have been these in our editorial assembly this week who opined that truly San Marino 2005, taken as an entire, was fairly a boring race. However right here we’re coming into the territory of different cognitive biases influenced by our information of the result.
Such is life on the hedonic treadmill: we by no means enable ourselves to be pleased with what we’ve acquired.
Learn Additionally:
Commercial
Typically the chase is healthier than the catch
Filip Cleeren, Motorsport.com International:
When this dialogue comes up I am usually reminded of two extremes, the 2005 San Marino Grand Prix and the 2013 Indy 500.
Famously, at Imola Alonso was hounded lap after lap by Schumacher within the , with the good German unable to discover a well past. It was powerful to maintain your eyes off, and that was with out an overtake really being made. Typically the chase is healthier than the catch.
Commercial
I used to be fortunate sufficient to be on the 500 in 2013 and witness a preferred win for , however the race actually made the historical past books for its mind-boggling 68 overtakes for the lead. That is one each three laps. Because the automobiles have been again then, with their cumbersome rear bumpers, the chief was a sitting duck, so whereas passes at first and end of the race have been important and entertaining, the bulk within the center a part of the race felt inconsequential and synthetic.
Tony Kanaan, KV Racing Know-how Chevrolet takes the win
Tony Kanaan, KV Racing Know-how Chevrolet takes the win
Discovering a cheerful center floor, to me, is about making certain driving talent is making a distinction. F1 automobiles must be tough sufficient to drive so drivers are punished for errors, and it must be simple sufficient to observe for the motive force behind to pounce on these, or make a distinction on pure tempo however with out simply breezing previous early on the straights.
Commercial
I would gladly take a pair fewer overtakes than we’ve got seen in 2026 with out among the battery-induced ‘yo-yo racing’, however I additionally perceive a return to 2005 isn’t going to chop it from a spectator viewpoint. F1 should discover a method to stability meritocracy versus leisure, which is simpler mentioned than performed in a post-refuelling period with much less room for technique to make a distinction.
There is not any worth in overtakes made “by chance”
Stefan Ehlen, Motorsport.com Germany:
Commercial
All of it will depend on what you outline as an “overtake”: a real transfer the place one driver outbrakes one other and earns the place by talent and racecraft? Or a man-made cross within the DRS period, the place one driver merely occurs to have the ability to deploy extra energy at a given second?
Personally, I vastly choose real overtaking strikes — high quality over amount. For the reason that introduction of the Drag Discount System (DRS) within the 2011 season, Components 1 has seen far too many low cost place adjustments, which then hit new heights at first of the 2026 season beneath the brand new technical rules with all of the “power administration” concerned.
In fact, persons are free to take pleasure in these fixed place swaps. They actually look spectacular. However to me, lots of them really feel fairly meaningless as a result of they’re so closely depending on circumstance. When even the drivers themselves admit that they often overtake “by chance” as a result of the tech-assisted automobile successfully dictates the transfer, then the sporting worth of such manoeuvres needs to be questioned.
Commercial
I might a lot fairly see a handful of actual overtakes per race — strikes which can be rigorously arrange, preceded by a hard-fought battle, or executed with real cleverness. Easy drive-by passes do little or no for me personally. They lack the ingredient of sporting achievement.
Lando Norris, McLaren, Andrea Kimi Antonelli, Mercedes
Lando Norris, McLaren, Andrea Kimi Antonelli, Mercedes
No, although that is what many followers wished (and now reject)
Jose Carlos de Celis, Motorsport.com Spain:
All too usually, social media has been flooded with feedback labelling any random F1 race as “probably the most boring,” exactly due to an absence of overtaking and, simply as incessantly, the existence of these DRS trains the place nobody passes anybody. Everybody fortunately embraced the concept by 2026 there can be extra overtaking, forgetting that this isn’t all the time synonymous with extra pleasure, and now that’s exactly what many are criticising.
Commercial
Folks say that the overtaking in 2026 is synthetic, forgetting that DRS was too, and though I’m not a robust defender of those guidelines – I’ll have gone mad the day I really like an F1 automobile that runs out of energy on the straights – however wasn’t extra overtaking what followers have been asking for?
Each April (or each time F1 returns to Imola), movies go viral reminding us that twenty years in the past, on the 2005 and 2006 San Marino GPs, first Alonso gained by heading off Schumacher for a lot of laps, and the next yr Schumacher did the identical. And talking of Alonso, I’m certain most of his followers bear in mind with extra pleasure – past the podiums he achieved in 2023 – the 2021 Hungarian GP the place gained, partly because of a masterful defence by Alonso towards .
In different phrases, thrilling battles don’t all the time have to finish in overtakes, as a result of they may also be nice strikes to carry place. Though there would all the time be one other side to criticise. As a result of it is mentioned that ‘you possibly can’t please everybody’, and I’d add you could by no means create F1 guidelines that please everybody.
Commercial
It is about high quality, not amount
Federico Faturos, Motorsport.com Latin America:
I will be very trustworthy right here: Components 1 celebrating the sheer variety of overtakes at first of this new guidelines period felt, at greatest, like an entire misreading of the scenario. And issues solely turned worse when Stefano Domenicali himself stored pushing the narrative as if it have been the best factor conceivable, just for to clarify what the truth really seems like.
Commercial
In fact, a race with overtaking is healthier than a race with out overtaking. However that alone doesn’t inform the total story. If these passes occur past the motive force’s management as a result of the battery deployment had already determined the result, in the event that they happen just because one driver has used up his power and is left defenceless afterwards… then sure, technically, they’re overtakes. However what’s their actual worth?
Lewis Hamilton, Ferrari
Lewis Hamilton, Ferrari
Possibly it’s as a result of I get near 40 and now not absolutely align with the logic of youthful audiences, though I’ve all the time thought-about myself old skool relating to debates like this. I by no means preferred DRS both. Even that already felt synthetic.
Commercial
An overtake on the pinnacle of motorsport must be the results of a racing driver — an athlete — pushing their machine to absolutely the restrict of grip, braking impossibly late, committing utterly, forcing their well past a rival who’s concurrently doing all the pieces doable to defend and maintain on to trace place.
Does anybody genuinely bear in mind any of the a whole bunch of overtakes we’ve got seen up to now in the course of the 2026 season? Has any of them actually stood out? Will folks nonetheless be sharing clips of them on social media 10 years from now?
The reply isn’t any. We are going to nonetheless bear in mind strikes like on at Hungary 1986, Mansell towards Piquet at Silverstone 1987, on Schumacher at Spa in 2000, or on Schumacher at Brazil 2001, simply to call a couple of.
Components 1 doesn’t want extra overtakes. It wants extra unforgettable ones.
To learn extra Motorsport.com articles .
